The puzzle of procyclical labor productivity occupies an important pos
ition in the debate over Real Business Cycle Theory. Real Business Cyc
le proponents attribute it to procyclical technology shocks, opponents
to ''labor hoarding''-retention during recessions of workers not need
ed for current production, thus downwardly biasing productivity measur
ements. This paper uses a model featuring heterogeneous industries to
illustrate that the conventional presumption of counter-cyclical aggre
gate labor hoarding generating procyclical productivity measurements i
s not necessarily well grounded in theory.