H. Zwolfer et W. Volkl, INFLUENCE OF BEHAVIOR PATTERNS OF ADULT I NSECTS ON RESOURCE UTILIZATION AND POPULATION-DYNAMICS - A MODEL OF POPULATION-CONTROL BY 3 MAJORCOMPONENTS, Entomologia generalis, 21(3), 1997, pp. 129-144
Bottom-up processes (limitation by resources) and top-down processes (
limitation by antagonists) are usually considered to be the driving fo
rces in the population dynamics of insects. This view implies that a p
ermanent underutilization of resources by phytophagous insects or para
sitoids is due to population control by natural enemies and/or disease
organisms. Our contribution presents examples of phytophagous insects
and parasitoids with a level of resource utilization which cannot be
satisfactorily explained by the dichotomy of bottom-up and top-down pr
ocesses. We start by defining the term ''available resources''. We the
n bring an evaluation of the success rate of biocontrol agents introdu
ced against allochthonous noxious weeds in Canada A recent status repo
rt [HARRIS 1995] shows that a considerable number of phytophagous inse
ct species established in Canada without their specialized natural ene
mies exploit only a small proportion of the available biomass of host
plants. For one of these species, the tephritid gallformer Urophora ca
rdui, we show that its host selection behaviour leads to a spatial dis
persion pattern of galls resulting in a strongly inverse density depen
dence of resource utilization. Further examples of an underutilization
of hosts are given for parasitoids attacking Urophora species in flow
er heads of Centaurea and for parasitoids of aphids. Neither a bottom-
up nor a direct top-down process, but rather specific behaviour patter
ns are involved in these cases of resource underutilization. These pat
terns may be adaptive in the sense of ''spreading the risk'', of escap
ing enemies operating in a density-dependent manner or as a trade-off
between host quality and host quantity. They may also be historically
constrained. To account for the possible impact of behaviour, we propo
se to replace the dichotomy of bottom-up and top-down processes by a t
riangle scheme where changing combinations of resource limitation, lim
itation by antagonists and specific behaviour patterns control populat
ion densities.