Td. Cannon et E. Marco, STRUCTURAL BRAIN ABNORMALITIES AS INDICATORS OF VULNERABILITY TO SCHIZOPHRENIA, Schizophrenia bulletin, 20(1), 1994, pp. 89-102
The literature on structural brain abnormalities in schizophrenia is e
xamined to determine whether these abnormalities represent viable cand
idate markers of vulnerability to the disorder. A majority of studies
agree in finding that schizophrenia patients as a group have significa
ntly larger ventricles and smaller limbic brain structures than normal
control subjects, but about 50 percent of patients fall within the ra
nge of control subjects on these measures. This result has been interp
reted to suggest that structural abnormalities characterize only a sub
group of patients. However, given the substantial degree of normal var
iability in brain structure between families, the use of biologically
unrelated individuals as controls is misleading. Studies that have com
pared schizophrenia patients with their unaffected first-degree relati
ves have found a much higher sensitivity rate for ventricular enlargem
ent and reduced limbic volumes (i.e., 70%-100%). This high within-fami
ly sensitivity, together with evidence from metaanalytic reviews of a
substantial relationship between ventricular enlargement and severity
of illness, argues in favor of a continuous distribution of the brain
pathology in schizophrenia and against a model in which the pathology
characterizes only a subgroup of patients. The structural abnormalitie
s observed in both younger and older patients have been found to be hi
ghly correlated with familial risk for schizophrenia and obstetric com
plications, suggesting that some part of the deviance may be present i
n the premorbid state and that it may reflect both genetic and environ
mental etiologic processes. The evidence for specificity of the defici
ts to schizophrenia is equivocal, but no study has yet compared the wi
thin-family sensitivities of morphological measures among the major ps
ychiatric conditions. Additional studies using first-degree relatives
and well-defined neuroanatomical measurements are needed to determine
which brain regions have the highest sensitivities as indicators of sc
hizophrenia in families.