N. Brewer et al., SUPERVISORY BEHAVIOR AND TEAM PERFORMANCE AMONGST POLICE PATROL SERGEANTS, Journal of occupational and organizational psychology, 67, 1994, pp. 69-78
This study examined the generality of Komaki's operant model of superv
ision (Komaki, 1986; Komaki, Zlotnik & jensen 1986; Komaki, Desselles
& Bowman, 1989) in an organizational setting characterized by a formal
chain of command. Ratings of subordinate performance were used to ind
ex supervisory effectiveness. Using the Operant Supervisory Taxonomy a
nd Index, measures of supervisory behaviour were obtained from 20 poli
ce patrol sergeants over a period of several months. Compared with sup
ervisors in other settings, police sergeants spent less time providing
antecedents (i.e. instructions, rules, goals) and consequences (i.e.
feedback), and more time monitoring subordinates' performance. Sergean
ts of higher performing teams spent more time monitoring performance a
nd providing neutral performance consequences. In contrast with earlie
r findings, monitoring via work sampling was not related to subordinat
e performance. Performance was, however, related to the time superviso
rs spent soliciting self-reports from subordinates, and the time they
allocated to those solitary activities which provided more opportuniti
es for monitoring subordinates' performance. The findings were consist
ent with Komaki et al.'s (1986) operant conceptualization of how super
visors motivate their subordinates.