H. Nommik et al., ISOTOPIC FRACTIONATION ACCOMPANYING FERTILIZER NITROGEN TRANSFORMATIONS IN SOIL AND TREES OF A SCOTS SPINE ECOSYSTEM, Plant and soil, 158(2), 1994, pp. 169-182
Foliage from a mature stand of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) receiv
ing increasing doses of ammonium nitrate and urea nitrogen was assayed
during the five subsequent growing seasons for total N concentration
and N-15 abundance. The aim of the study was to examine the potential
of the delta(15)N technique to provide estimates on fertilizer N recov
ery and its fate in the ecosystem. The N-15 abundance in the foliage i
ncreased in proportion to the dose of fertilizer application. This was
generally owing to the fact that the delta(15)N of the fertilizer N w
as significantly higher than that in the soil inorganic-N pool, as wel
l as in the needle biomass of the Scots pine trees on the nonfertilize
d plots. Due to N-15 isotope discrimination occurring during N transfo
rmations in soil the relationship was however not very close. Calculat
ions based on the principle of isotope dilution yielded only rough and
, in some cases, even misleading estimates of the fraction of the fert
ilizer-derived nitrogen (N-dff) in the needles. This was especially th
e case for the urea-N, which undergoes significant isotopic fractionat
ion during the process of ammonia volatilization and possibly microbia
l NH4+ assimilation in soil. Over five growing seasons, foliar total N
concentration peaked at the end of the second season while the N-15 a
bundance continued to increase. Although large methodological errors m
ay be involved when interpreting natural N-15 abundance, the measureme
nt of delta(15)N seems to provide semi-quantitative information about
fertilizer N accumulation and transformation processes in coniferous e
cosystems. A better understanding of the tree and soil processes causi
ng isotopic fractionation is a prerequisite for correct interpretation
of N-15 data.