The author discusses three programs of school reform developed for the
federal states of Bremen, Hamburg, and North Rhine-Westfalia, respect
ively aimed at overcoming the stalemate of educational policy debates
during the last decade. Despite differences in the definition of tasks
for the three commissions responsible for the recommendations it can
be shown that they fully agree on the basic objectives of school refor
m and on the principles guiding reform strategies. All three start fro
m the premise that a reform proposing a single structural model of an
integrated school is doomed to fail, and it is against this background
that they discuss possibilities and procedures of a partial integrati
on of schooling beyond the Primary stage. That the individual school w
ill be the principal actor in further school development is, according
ly, a basic assumption in all three reports. The corresponding changes
in the structure and function of school administration are developed
in detail by the North Rhine-Westfalian commission. Results of empiric
al research that cast doubt on the feasibility of some of the recommen
dations receive little attention in the three reports.