Fifty-six asthmatics from an asthma ward or from an asthma out-patient
clinic were challenged with two low concentrations (0.03 and 0.012 mg
) of metacholine chloride in order to assess the relationship between
pronounced hyper-responsiveness and asthma severity in a clinical sett
ing. Only inhaled bronchodilators were stopped before challenge. Asthm
a severity was assessed retrospectively and prospectively on the basis
of treatment, number of days in hospital, intensive care, number of e
mergency visits and days on sick-le ave. The results show that pronoun
ced hyper-responsiveness (n=28) is not associated with asthma severity
. It is concluded that a single simplified test of pronounced bronchia
l hyper-responsiveness, performed without taking into consideration th
e actual state of the disease and without stopping all medication, is
of no help in identifying the patients with the clinically most severe
asthma and worst prognosis.