Ms. Soloway et al., RESULTS OF RADICAL CYSTECTOMY FOR TRANSITIONAL-CELL CARCINOMA OF THE BLADDER AND THE EFFECT OF CHEMOTHERAPY, Cancer, 73(7), 1994, pp. 1926-1931
Background. Radical cystectomy continues to be one of the primary moda
lities of treatment for locally advanced bladder cancer. However, long
-term survival after cystectomy has improved only marginally in the la
st decade, and still, nearly half of the patients die from the disease
within 5 years. Adjuvant treatments such as radiation therapy and che
motherapy have been used, but a clear advantage has not been demonstra
ted. Methods. The authors reviewed 130 patients who underwent radical
cystectomy by the same surgeon as treatment for transitional cell carc
inoma of the bladder. Morbidity, postoperative mortality, overall surv
ival time, and accuracy of clinical staging as well as the effect of p
erioperative chemotherapy were evaluated. Results. The overall actuari
al survival rate at 2, 5, and 10 years was 80%, 53%, and 45%, respecti
vely. The survival rate based on T-classification at 5 years was 82%,
65%, and 28% for less than pT2, pT2, and greater than pT2, respectivel
y. Regional lymph node status had a significant effect on survival. Th
e 5-year survival rate for all patients with negative nodes was 65%, w
hereas patients with positive nodes had a 18% 5-year survival rate. Th
e overall clinical staging error was 61.5%, with 41.5% of the cancers
understaged. Of the patients with cTis, 60% were found to be of greate
r extent than pT1 tumors. No apparent survival advantage was noted for
those patients who received perioperative chemotherapy when compared
with patients who were followed conservatively or received chemotherap
y upon relapse. These results, however, are not conclusive because thi
s was an observation study and the number of patients was limited. Con
clusions. Only a modest improvement in survival time after radical cys
tectomy has been observed in the last decade, despite the use of adjuv
ant treatments such as radiation and chemotherapy. The pathologic (pT)
classification is the most accurate prognostic indicator. Clinical er
rors in classification are common and impair the evaluation of neoadju
vant treatments. A high incidence of invasive tumors of greater extent
than pT1 was found among patients with clinical cTis; this supports a
n aggressive approach when these patients do not respond promptly to i
ntravesical chemotherapy. Prospective randomized studies are needed to
evaluate objectively the benefit of perioperative adjuvant treatment
in locally advanced transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder.