Cyc. Pak et al., SLOW-RELEASE SODIUM-FLUORIDE IN THE MANAGEMENT OF POSTMENOPAUSAL OSTEOPOROSIS - A RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL, Annals of internal medicine, 120(8), 1994, pp. 625-632
Objective: To test whether intermittent treatment with slow-release so
dium fluoride and continuous calcium citrate supplementation inhibits
vertebral fractures without causing fluoride complications. Design:A p
lacebo-controlled, randomized trial. Setting: Outpatient setting of sp
ecialty clinics in Dallas and Temple, Texas. Interventions: Slow-relea
se sodium fluoride (25 mg twice daily) in repeated 14-month cycles (12
months on treatment followed by 2 months off treatment) compared with
placebo. Both groups took calcium citrate (400 mg calcium twice daily
) continuously. P Patients: 110 patients with postmenopausal osteoporo
sis were randomly assigned to two groups. In the slow-release sodium f
luoride group, 48 of 54 patients completed more than 1 cycle of treatm
ent (mean, 2.44 cycles/patient), whereas 51 of 56 patients in the plac
ebo group completed at least 1 cycle (mean, 2.14 cycles/patient) in th
is interim analysis. Measurements: Vertebral fracture rate and lumbar
bone mineral content. Vertebral fractures were quantified from yearly
radiographs. Bone mass was determined annually by densitometry. Result
s: In the sodium fluoride group, the mean L2 to L4 bone mineral conten
t increased by 4% to 6% in each cycle and the mean femoral neck bone d
ensity increased by 4.1% and 2.1% during the first two cycles, but the
radial bone density did not change, The placebo group showed no stati
stical change in bane mass at any site. Compared with the placebo grou
p, the sodium fluoride group had, a lower individual new vertebral fra
cture rate (0.057/patient cycle compared with 0.204/ patient cycle, P
= 0.017), a higher fracture-free rate (83.3% compared with 64.7%, P =
0.042), and a lower group fracture rate (0.085/patient cycle compared
with 0.239/patient cycle, P = 0.006). The side-effect profile was simi
lar for the two groups; no patient developed microfractures, hip fract
ures, or blood loss anemia. s Conclusions: Intermittent slow-release s
odium fluoride plus continuous calcium citrate, administered for about
2.5 years, inhibits new vertebral fractures, increases the mean spina
l bone mass without decreasing the radial shaft bone density, and is s
afe to use.