1. Body size is a central element in current theories of life-history
evolution. Models for optimal age at maturity are based on the assumpt
ions that there is a trade-off between development time and adult size
and that larger size provides a reproductive advantage. 2. The result
s of large, replicated experiments with the water strider Gerris bueno
i (Heteroptera: Gerridae) contradict both these assumptions. Individua
l rearings under field conditions showed that there is a negative, not
a positive, correlation between development time and adult size. The
physiological basis of growth, with stretch-induced moulting, may prov
ide a partial explanation for this correlation. 3. This study examined
a number of fitness components for their correlations with female siz
e: lifetime fecundity, reproductive life span, average volume per egg,
total volume of eggs laid, and the proportion of eggs hatched. None o
f these traits was correlated with female size. 4. The data on water s
triders suggest an alternative scenario for life-history evolution, in
which size is not an adaptive trait, but evolves as a correlated resp
onse to selection on other traits. This expands the range of possible
models, and opens life-history theory to the debate about adaptation a
nd optimality.