5-YEAR CLINICAL AND FUNCTIONAL OUTCOME COMPARING BYPASS-SURGERY AND ANGIOPLASTY IN PATIENTS WITH MULTIVESSEL CORONARY-DISEASE - A MULTICENTER RANDOMIZED TRIAL
El. Alderman et al., 5-YEAR CLINICAL AND FUNCTIONAL OUTCOME COMPARING BYPASS-SURGERY AND ANGIOPLASTY IN PATIENTS WITH MULTIVESSEL CORONARY-DISEASE - A MULTICENTER RANDOMIZED TRIAL, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 277(9), 1997, pp. 715-721
Objective.-To compare clinical and functional status in patients who h
ad similar 5-year survival after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG
) and percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA). Design.-R
andomized trial of 1829 patients followed for an average 5.4 years. Pa
rticipants.-Patients with multivessel coronary artery disease suitable
for both CABG and PTCA and not previously revascularized. Interventio
n.-Coronary artery bypass grafting or PTCA within 2 weeks after random
ization. Outcome Measures.-Symptoms, exercise test results, medication
use, and quality-of-life measures collected at 4 to 14 weeks, and at
1, 3, and 5 years after randomization. Analysis.-Intention to treat. R
esults.-Differences in angina-free rates between patients assigned to
PTCA and CABG decreased from 73% vs 95% at 4 to 14 weeks (P<.001) to 7
9% vs 85% at 5 years (P=.007). Similar patterns were observed for exer
cise-induced angina and ischemia, except 5-year differences were not s
ignificant. At follow-up of 1 year and later, quality of life, return
to work, modification of smoking and exercise behaviors, and cholester
ol levels were similar for the 2 treatments. Compared with patients as
signed to CABG, use of anti-ischemic medication was higher in patients
assigned to PTCA, while smaller differences were observed for other m
edications. Among patients angina-free at 5 years, 52% of patients who
had PTCA required revascularization after the initial procedure vs 6%
of patients who had CABG. Conclusions.-The narrowing of treatment dif
ferences in angina and exercise-induced ischemia rates can be attribut
ed to a return of symptoms among patients assigned to CABG and increme
ntal surgical procedures among patients assigned to PTCA. Patients ass
igned to PTCA apparently were able to tolerate higher rates of residua
l ischemia as evidenced by comparable quality of life and 5-year survi
val.