Wd. Watson, BASIC THEORY FOR POLARIZED, ASTROPHYSICAL MASER RADIATION IN A MAGNETIC-FIELD, The Astrophysical journal, 424(1), 1994, pp. 120000037-120000039
Fundamental alterations in the theory and resulting behavior of polari
zed, astrophysical maser radiation in the presence of a magnetic field
have been asserted based on a calculation of instabilities in the rad
iative transfer. I reconsider the radiative transfer and find that the
relevant instabilities do not occur. Calculational errors in the prev
ious investigation are identified. In addition, such instabilities wou
ld have appeared but did not-in the numerous numerical solutions to th
e same radiative transfer equations that have been presented in the li
terature. As a result, all modifications that have been presented in a
recent series of papers (Elitzur 1991, 1993) to the theory for polari
zed maser radiation in the presence of a magnetic field are invalid. T
he basic theory is thus clarified.