P. Palange et al., CARDIOPULMONARY EXERCISE TESTING IN THE EVALUATION OF PATIENTS WITH VENTILATORY VS CIRCULATORY CAUSES OF REDUCED EXERCISE TOLERANCE, Chest, 105(4), 1994, pp. 1122-1126
Introduction: Cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPX) is considered a u
seful procedure in the evaluation of circulatory, ventilatory, or mixe
d origin of reduced exercise tolerance. Our study was designed to comp
are CPX and a standard clinical-instrumental approach in the evaluatio
n of patients with cardiopulmonary disorders. Methods: Fifty-seven pat
ients (31 male, 26 female; mean [+/-SE] age, 60+/-2 years) were studie
d. Each patient was evaluated by two different observers: one used sta
ndard clinical criteria, the other used gas exchange indexes, monitore
d during a maximal incremental CPX, performed on a cycle ergometer; Ca
rdiac output (CO), at rest and at submaximal work level, was also obta
ined. Results: In 46 patients (80.7 percent), a concordant evaluation
was reached by the two observers (24 were found to have a predominant
ventilatory disorder, to have a circulatory disorder); among these, su
bjects considered to have circulatory impairment, the maximal CO/maxim
al workload ratio was significantly lower than in the ventilatory grou
p; in those with ventilatory impairment, the reduced exercise toleranc
e correlated with the resting spirometric values. In the remaining 11
patients (19.3 percent), CPX better defined the underlying pathophysio
logy of exercise limitation: in 10 of them, clinically classified as h
aving a mixed or predominantly ventilatory disorder, a greater importa
nce of the circulatory component was detected; 4 had evidence of pulmo
nary vascular impairment (high VE/V-CO2 at -anaerobic threshold). Conc
lusions: Our study confirmed the sensitivity of CPX in the evaluation
of a reduced exercise tolerance in dyspneic patients with cardiopulmon
ary conditions; when compared with a clinical-laboratory approach, in
some patients it allowed the detection of an underestimated circulator
y component causing exercise limitation.