Sc. Rogers et al., AB-INITIO MOLECULAR-ORBITAL CALCULATIONS ON THE Q-E SCHEME FOR PREDICTING REACTIVITY IN FREE-RADICAL COPOLYMERIZATION, Polymer, 35(6), 1994, pp. 1258-1267
Ab initio molecular orbital calculations have been performed on the re
actions of unsaturated monomers with both hydrogen and methyl radicals
. These calculations have utilized several basis sets, namely STO-3G,
SV3-21G, SV Dunning and triple zeta valence. The correlation between t
he experimental Q and the energy of formation of the product radical w
as examined, whilst the electronegativity of the monomer was correlate
d with the e parameter. In addition, a Q-e-e-type scheme was analysed
to correct for the simplification in the standard Q-e scheme that the
monomer and the radical are identical with respect to their charge di
stributions. In this instance experimental e parameters were correlate
d with the average electronegativity of monomer and radical. This work
shows that correlations exist between these parameters as other simpl
er studies (based on Huckel calculations) have reported. However, whil
e the correlations with both e and the e-e average parameter were pre
dictive, the relationship between Q and a general reactivity of the ra
dical proved only qualitative. A statistical analysis of the data reve
aled a significant polar influence on this relationship; by taking thi
s into account we were able to improve the correlation. We also rescal
ed the Q-e scheme as suggested by other authors and correlated the res
ults of our calculations with the new numbers. This work emphasizes th
e difficulties in correlation analysis, which requires the separation
and parameterization of polar, steric and general reactivity effects.
It also stresses the requirement for accurate experimental data.