Pj. Held et al., CONTINUOUS AMBULATORY PERITONEAL-DIALYSIS AND HEMODIALYSIS - COMPARISON OF PATIENT MORTALITY WITH ADJUSTMENT FOR COMORBID CONDITIONS, Kidney international, 45(4), 1994, pp. 1163-1169
A historical prospective national sample of 1,725 diabetic and 2,411 n
on-diabetic Medicare end-stage renal disease (ESRD) patients incident
from 1986 to 1987 was analyzed for the mortality of patients selected
to receive continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) or hemodia
lysis (HD) with adjustment for patient characteristics, including the
presence of comorbid conditions at onset of ESRD. Cox proportional haz
ards analyses were used to compare the mortality of CAPD and HD patien
ts. Patients were followed from 30 days following onset of ESRD until
two to four years post-onset. No statistically significant difference
in relative mortality risk (RR) was found among non-diabetic patients
selected for CAPD compared to HD (RR = 0.84 for CAPD versus HD, P = 0.
25), while evidence of higher adjusted mortality for CAPD compared to
HD was found among diabetic patients (RR = 1.26, P = 0.03). Mortality
analyses adjusted for pre-treatment risk factors suggest that CAPD and
HD provide incident non-diabetic ESRD patients with similar expected
survival outcomes. Evidence that increased mortality was associated wi
th CAPD among diabetic patients, particularly among elderly patients,
suggests the need for further controlled studies of mortality among CA
PD patients with diabetes.