Gm. Davis et al., MOLECULAR-GENETIC AND ANATOMICAL RELATIONSHIPS AMONG POMATIOPSID (GASTROPODA, PROSOBRANCHIA) GENERA FROM SOUTHERN CHINA, Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, 145, 1994, pp. 191-207
Allozyme electrophoresis was employed to assess the relationships amon
g key genera of Chinese Triculinae and Oncomelania of the Pomatiopsina
e, subfamilies of the Pomatiopsidae (Gastropoda: Rissoacea). We assess
the degree to which the subfamilies have differentiated genetically,
test the congruence of relationships based on anatomical and allozyme
data, calibrate genetic distances among triculine genera where the bas
is of generic definition is the anatomical data set, and assess interp
opulation variation for species widely dispersed throughout China. The
interpopulation study was on Oncomelania hupensis from three location
s in Zhejiang Province. Interpopulation difference does not exceed Nei
's D of 0.191. The greatest amount of interpopulation D is associated
with shell sculpture, not geographic distance. Nei's D ranges from 1.0
to 1.76 for divergence of Oncomelania from the three triculine taxa s
tudied. The inter-triculine differences range from 0.69 to 1.24. Pheno
grams of relationships based on a UPGMA treatment of Nei's 1972 D, Wri
ght's modified Rogers' D, and Cavalli-Sforza and Edwards' Arc distance
are congruent with a cladogram based on scoring each locus as a chara
cter. Oncomelania is the outlier, but not by much thus showing a close
genetic relationship to the triculine taxa. There is a closer relatio
nship between Oncomelania and one triculine taxon than between two tri
culine taxa. Genetic data support the contention that the Pomatiopsina
e and the Triculinae are derived from a common ancestor and are histor
ically closely related. The cladistic analysis of anatomical data is c
ongruent with the cladogram and phenograms based on allozyme data. The
se results support the large-scale cladistic analyses of the Triculina
e that are based on anatomical data. The anatomical data, not the allo
zymic data, strongly support the subfamily arrangement currently used.
A phenetic analysis of the anatomical data indicates that two species
provisionally placed in Gammatricula should be placed in separate gen
era. The genetic data support this view.