This article analyzes the optimal dynamic strategy of a risk-averse ag
ent bearing an insurable risk to determine whether precautionary savin
g is superior to insurance in the long run. The risk of loss is descri
bed by a Poisson process. Policyholders can purchase insurance and/or
accumulate precautionary savings in order to forearm themselves in the
face of uncertainty. It is shown that the demand for insurance vanish
es in the long run if the loading factor exceeds a.critical value whic
h is strictly positive. However, insurance may be a transitory strateg
y to protect capital accumulation. The optimal strategy for capital ac
cumulation and insurance demand is derived in the constant relative ri
sk aversion case. It is also shown that compulsory full insurance redu
ces the rate of consumption if and only if risk aversion exceeds one.