As a young physician the poet Gottfried Benn (1886-1956) gave up a pro
mising career in psychiatry after short period in practice. A psychody
namic analysis of this failure stresses the importance of the relation
ship of father and son in adolescence for the maturing of ego identity
and ego ideal. At the beginning of this century psychiatry was a medi
cal field with strong materialistic and biologistic positions. Benn em
braced this position and tried to distance himself from his father, wh
o was a charismatic priest with psychotherapeutic ambition. Benn exper
ienced difficulty in competing with his father and this can be attribu
ted to disturbances in his relationship to his mother in early childho
od. The consequence was e.g. a narcisstic vulnerability in adulthood.
The contrast of the splendid success in brain research with its inappl
icability in routine therapy was characteristic of the state of psychi
atry at the time of Benn's failure.