B. Schmid et Fa. Bazzaz, CROWN CONSTRUCTION, LEAF DYNAMICS, AND CARBON GAIN IN 2 PERENNIALS WITH CONTRASTING ARCHITECTURE, Ecological monographs, 64(2), 1994, pp. 177-203
We used two co-occurring plant species of similar size and leaf morpho
logy but with contrasting architecture to test if they would show spec
ific patterns of leaf demography and leaf ecophysiology when they were
grown in a range of experimental environments. Aster lanceolatus, a s
pecies with branched shoots, had exponentially increasing leaf populat
ions. This led to high leaf turnover rates and to crowding of leaves a
t the top of the plants. Solidago canadensis, a species with unbranche
d shoots and rapid height growth, had linearly increasing populations
of leaves, leading to a uniform vertical distribution of leaves and to
lower leaf turnover rates. In comparison with the short-lived leaves
of A. lanceolatus, the leaves of S. canadensis lived longer, contained
more nitrogen and calcium per dry mass, and responded to changing lig
ht conditions within the plant crown by adjusting their angles towards
the sun. Leaves of A. lanceolatus had an early peak in gas exchange a
ctivity followed by a rapid decline, whereas gas exchange activity in
leaves of S. canadensis at the beginning of leaf development was lower
than in A. lanceolatus but decreased only slightly with leaf age. Wit
hin the narrow vertical band in which leaves of A. lanceolatus were co
ncentrated, young leaves at the top had higher mass per area, higher c
hlorophyll alb ratios, and much higher rates of photosynthesis and con
ductance than the older leaves beneath. In S. canadensis, in which lea
ves were distributed over much of the vertical dimension along the pla
nt, upper leaves, in contrast to lower (older) leaves, had lower mass
per area, were held less perpendicular to the sun, and had higher rate
s of photosynthesis in high but not in low light. Because leaf populat
ions grew exponentially in A. lanceolatus, assimilates could be re-inv
ested; thus leaf number during the second half of the growing season w
as a good predictor of final biomass. In S. canadensis, with linearly
growing leaf populations, the assimilates that were not re-invested in
new leaves were allocated to the stem, and stem height or volume were
good predictors of final biomass. Compared with the strong influence
of architecture on the structure and dynamics of leaf populations, the
effects of background species and fertilizer application were weak bu
t nevertheless significant. Background species of similar aboveground
mass but different stature (the tall Solidago altissima and the short
Poa pratensis) affected leaf deployment (internode elongation, leaf or
ientation, and leaf survival), probably via competition for light, but
not leaf quality (morphology, physiology) of the two target species A
. lanceolatus and S. canadensis. Further, diameter-height allometries,
which varied considerably among plants, tended to be flatter if the t
arget species were grown in the tall than in the short background. Fer
tilizer application accelerated plant growth and phenological developm
ent. It increased light competition among leaves and leaf turnover; ne
vertheless, the photosynthetic water use efficiency of old leaves was
higher in fertilized than in unfertilized plants. We suggest that the
characteristic leaf dynamics of A. lanceolatus and S. canadensis are t
ypical for the contrasting aboveground architectures these species rep
resent. Based on the results of this and previous studies we suggest t
hat an important driving force in the evolution of these complex adapt
ations is the degree of mixing within canopies of leaves of different
plant genotypes. Leaves (and branches) are expected to be more autonom
ous if they frequently interact with leaves from other genotypes, as i
n the polyclonal patches of A. lanceolatus with its long and interming
ling belowground rhizomes, than if they usually interact with leaves f
rom the same genotype, as in the monoclonal patches of S. canadensis w
ith its short rhizomes and compact belowground architecture.