P. Dekeyser et al., 2-WEEK ORAL TREATMENT OF TINEA-PEDIS, COMPARING TERBINAFINE (250 MG DAY) WITH ITRACONAZOLE (100 MG/DAY) - A DOUBLE-BLIND, MULTICENTER STUDY/, British journal of dermatology, 130, 1994, pp. 22-25
In this randomized double-blind trial, two new antifungal compounds we
re compared in patients with interdigital or more extensive forms of t
inea pedis. Two weeks of oral treatment with either terbinafine, an al
lylamine and new chemical entity, 250 mg daily, or itraconazole 100 mg
daily, was given to 366 patients (184 terbinafine, 182 itraconazole).
Of 13 patients who did not return after the first visit, 11 were lost
to follow-up (five on terbinafine, six on itraconazole) and two repor
ted adverse events. Another nine patients (three on terbinafine and si
x on itraconazole) were excluded because it was uncertain to which gro
up they were randomized. A central laboratory performed both the mycol
ogy and safety tests. In 355 patients who received the study medicatio
ns and were available for analysis of side-effects, 18 out of 179 (10.
0%) in the terbinafine group and 10 out of 176 (5.7%) in the itraconaz
ole group reported adverse events. No new clinically significant labor
atory abnormalities were seen after treatment. At week 8 the efficacy
analysis in 117 patients with mycologically confirmed dermatophyte inf
ections (51 on terbinafine, 66 on itraconazole) showed that clinical s
ymptoms were absent or minimal in 94.1% of the terbinafine and 72.7% o
f the itraconazole group (P=0.0095); mycology was negative in 86.3% of
the terbinafine and 54.5% of the itraconazole group (P=0.0002). With
terbinafine, negative mycology at week 8 was 81.3% in the interdigital
and 88.6% in the more extensive forms of tinea pedis; with itraconazo
le mycology was negative in 65.0% and 50.0% of patients, respectively.
This study demonstrates that the primary fungicidal action of terbina
fine, i.e. its ability to kill fungi at minimal inhibitory concentrati
ons, is of substantial clinical and economic benefit to patients with
tinea pedis. After a 2-week oral treatment period of any form of tinea
pedis, terbinafine produced significantly higher mycological cure rat
es and significantly better clinical improvement than itraconazole.