Caste theory states that worker size distributions in ant colonies hav
e evolved for efficient division of labor and predicts that they shoul
d vary with habitat and have an effect on fitness. We tested these pre
dictions in a comparative study of worker size variation and colony fi
tness in Florida and Long Island populations of Trachymyrmex septentri
onalis. Colonies from the two populations were excavated shortly befor
e the time of the mating flights, so that workers and reproductive for
ms could be censused. We measured worker head widths in each colony an
d analyzed the resulting size frequency distributions using the mean,
standard deviation, skewness, and kurtosis, and also principal compone
nts derived from these parameters. Size frequency distributions were u
nimodal and close to normal, with a tendency to negative skewness. Col
onies in the Long Island population had both larger workers and greate
r size variation than those in Florida. Florida colonies followed a gr
owth trajectory in which the mean and standard deviation of worker hea
d width both increased with colony size, whereas in Long Island there
was an inverse relationship between the mean and standard deviation th
at was independent of colony size. Analysis based on the principal com
ponents showed that worker size variation significantly affected fitne
ss in both populations, and this was not a secondary effect of colony
size. Population differences in colony life history strategies may acc
ount for the observed patterns: the Long Island population appears to
be adapted for surviving the winter diapause, while the Florida popula
tion has experienced different selective pressures, possibly for rapid
colony growth. Size variation that has evolved in the context of life
history strategies may serve as a preadaptation for division of labor
.