Purpose. To determine if vitamin A could be one of the factors in seru
m responsible for the previously observed effect of 20% fetal bovine s
erum on stimulating clonal growth of an additional subpopulation in li
mbal cultures, possibly stem cells, but inhibiting that of transient a
mplifying cells in peripheral corneal cultures. Methods. A reported se
rum-free clonal growth assay was used. The mitogenic response was meas
ured by colony-forming efficiency (CFE), colony size, and BrdU labelin
g index; the differentiation was assessed by colony morphology, AE-5 m
onoclonal antibody staining, and cornified envelope formation. Results
. HPLC analyses revealed that added retinoic acid (RA) was rapidly tak
en up by cultured cells. As compared to the control without RA, low co
ncentrations of RA (10(-9) M to 10(-7) M) stimulated the CFE of limbal
cultures but did not change that of peripheral corneal cultures. Furt
hermore, 10(-8) M RA induced the emergence of two new types of colonie
s, one of which was almost exclusively present in limbal cultures, and
allowed continuous clonal growth of some colonies in late limbal cult
ures. RA also dose dependently reduced colony size and BrdU labeling i
ndex in both limbal and peripheral corneal cultures. RA in concentrati
ons above 10(-8) M stimulated normal differentiation of both limbal an
d peripheral corneal epithelial cells, as evidenced by increased AE-5
staining, but inhibited the formation of cornified envelopes, an index
for abnormal, squamous metaplasia, in late cultures. Conclusion. Thes
e results suggest that RA has a differential dose-dependent effect on
subpopulations of corneal and limbal epithelial cells. Although RA sti
mulates the conversion of limbal stem cells to transient amplifying ce
lls, it inhibits the amplification of corneal and limbal transient amp
lifying cells and prevents abnormal terminal differentiation. These da
ta further support the role of vitamin A as a physiological modulator
of proliferation and differentiation of the ocular surface epithelium.