S. Robertson et D. Elliott, THE INFLUENCE OF SKILL IN GYMNASTICS AND VISION ON DYNAMIC BALANCE, International journal of sport psychology, 27(4), 1996, pp. 361-368
In this study, the Authors examined the importance of vision in dynami
c balance at different stages of learning. Nine expert and 9 novice gy
mnasts were required to cross a balance beam as quickly as possible wi
th full vision, with no vision and with vision placed 15 degrees to th
e right and left. Expert gymnasts performed equally well in the full v
ision and no vision situation, but their performance deteriorated when
vision was displaced. Form errors were more pronounced in all three o
f the visually-degraded conditions. Novice gymnasts were adversely aff
ected by both the elimination of vision and displacement. This was tru
e for both the movement time and the form errors. These findings creat
e problems for models of motor learning that posit a progression from
closed-loop to open-loop control.