The results for inactivation of V79 cells irradiated by monoenergetic
deuterons with LET of 18, 26 and 31 keV.mum-1 and their direct compari
son with protons of comparable LET are presented. The experimental res
ults show that at 31 keV.mum-1 cell inactivation is similar for proton
s and deuterons while, at lower LET, deuterons appear to be less letha
l than protons. The use of parameters other than L(infinity), such as
L100 or Z2eff/beta2, does not completely reconcile the differences in
biological effectiveness among the particles pointing out their inadeq
uacy for describing the radiation quality of light ions. The experimen
tal results have been compared with the Monte Carlo track structure si
mulations, using the code MOCA 14, carried out for monoenergetic track
segments of protons, deuterons and alpha particles of selected LET in
the range 20-40 keV.mum-1. Existing track structure codes, and indeed
essentially all other physical descriptions of radiations used to dat
e, are unable to explain the observed differences in biological effect
iveness between deuterons and protons.