Strategic trade policy theory suggests how import protection can be ex
port-promoting under increasing returns to scale. I test this hypothes
is for 200 US import protection can be export-competing industries cha
racterized by varying degrees of increasing returns to scale. After re
moving political economy endogeneities in tariff and non-tariff barrie
rs. targeted import protection most frequently has been export-deterri
ng. Moreover, export deterrence has been greatest in industries displa
ying the strongest static or dynamic scale economies. These results ar
e consistent with earlier evidence that protection rarely stimulates d
omestic output and frequently promotes inefficient firm scale and entr
y.