The extensive variation in breeding traits of Mediterranean Blue Tits
(Parus caeruleus) is hypothesized to result from large differences in
the timing and abundance of food resources, depending on whether the d
ominant tree species of the habitat is deciduous (Quercus pubescens) o
r evergreen (Q. ilex). Data were collected on tree phenology, food abu
ndance (caterpillars), and breeding traits of tits in one mainland dec
iduous habitat, two mainland evergreen habitats, and one evergreen hab
itat on the island of Corsica. In the mainland deciduous habitat, an e
arly breeding time and a large clutch size were associated with an ear
ly and abundant food supply. In the evergreen habitats (both on mainla
nd and on Corsica), the leafing process occurred three weeks later and
the abundance of caterpillars, was much lower. On Corsica, tits start
ed to lay three weeks later than in the deciduous mainland habitat and
laid about 30% fewer eggs. As in the deciduous mainland habitat, the
breeding process seemed to be adjusted to the patterns of food availab
ility. In the two mainland evergreen habitats, tits started to breed e
arlier and laid more eggs than expected from the patterns of food avai
lability so that they mismatched the best period to raise their young.
The apparent maladaptation of tits in these evergreen mainland habita
ts is hypothesized to result from an asymmetric gene flow between rich
deciduous habitats (source), where well-adapted birds produce many fi
edglings, and poor evergreen habitats (sink), where the density is mai
ntained through immigration from rich habitats.