Ja. Massey et al., CONTRASTING RETROGRADE OXYGEN-ISOTOPE EXCHANGE BEHAVIOR AND IMPLICATIONS - EXAMPLES FROM THE LANGTANG VALLEY, NEPAL, Journal of metamorphic geology, 12(3), 1994, pp. 261-272
Quantitative modelling of oxygen exchange by diffusion during slow coo
ling has been compared to the observed oxygen isotope distributions fr
om high-grade metamorphic and granitic rocks of the High Himalayan Cry
stallines, Langtang Valley, central Nepal, in order to investigate the
effect of retrograde diffusional exchange on the preservation of high
-temperature, oxygen isotope systematics. Modelled fractionations, usi
ng water-present diffusion data reported in the literature, predict qu
artz-mica fractionations to be much larger than those at peak metamorp
hic and igneous conditions due to low closure temperatures for micas.
Quartz-feldspar fractionations may be less than those at peak conditio
ns, and in some samples may even be slightly negative. The observed ox
ygen isotope fractionations in the metamorphic rocks are small and lar
gely appear to record equilibrations close to peak conditions determin
ed by other methods. Hence these rocks clearly do not conform to predi
ctions of fluid-present diffusional retrograde exchange. It is suggest
ed that their retrograde history was therefore within an anhydrous clo
sed system in which diffusion was slow and hence mineral closure tempe
ratures were high. The granitic rocks record rather larger quartz-biot
ite fractionations, approaching those predicted by the diffusion model
ling. However, quartz-feldspar fractionations are large and hence, alt
hough significant retrograde exchange has clearly occurred, simple dif
fusion alone is not sufficient to explain the observed data and open-s
ystem exchange may be required. The presence of fluids during the retr
ograde history of this part of the section is supported by petrographi
c evidence.The different retrograde oxygen exchange histories recorded
between the regional metamorphic and magmatic regimes of the Langtang
section would appear to support the importance of water on the kineti
cs of such exchange, and suggests that in its absence, diffusional exc
hange may become insignificant, allowing oxygen isotope thermometry to
record meaningful high-temperature data.