Re. Dickerson et al., ... THE TYRANNY OF THE LATTICE ..., Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United Statesof America, 91(9), 1994, pp. 3579-3583
A systematic comparison of crystal structures of nine different B-DNA
dodecamers, in three different space groups, with and without A-tracts
, shows that crystal packing or lattice forces are of secondary import
ance for helix axis bending, minor-groove width, and propeller twist,
While other local helix parameters may be influenced or even establish
ed by crystal packing, the properties just enumerated are determined p
rimarily by base sequence. One and the same crystal packing scheme can
accommodate a bend in one of two different directions, or no bend at
all. A-tract regions of B-DNA are inherently straight and unbent, with
base-pair inclination no different from that of general-sequence B-DN
A. Where bends are observed at junctions between G.C and A.T regions,
they always involve a roll about base-pair long axes in a direction th
at compresses the wide major groove and, hence, are 90 degrees away fr
om that necessary for the correctness of the junction model of A-tract
bending. The G.C/A.T junction appears to be a flexible hinge, capable
of adopting either a straight or a bent conformation under the local
influence of weak crystal packing forces. Such forces therefore are a
source of information about DNA deformability and not a curse to be de
plored. But as an indication of the weakness of crystal packing forces
, introduction of a single bromine atom in the major groove is suffici
ent to eliminate a bend, although brominated and unbrominated crystals
are isomorphous.