Three species of the moss genus Climacium are recorded from North Amer
ica, but their systematic relationships have been unclear because of r
eports of morphological intergradation between them. Allopatric popula
tions of C. americanum and C. dendroides appear to be morphologically
distinct, but the two species intergrade in a broad region of sympatry
extending from Wisconsin to Massachusetts. We measured variation in t
wo morphological traits and isozyme genotypes at 19 loci in 253 plants
from six sites in New York state. The two species exhibited fixed all
elic differences at three loci (Aco-1, Hex-1, and Me-1). Moreover, Nei
's genetic identities between conspecific populations of the two speci
es were substantially higher (mean = 0.980 and 0.988 for C. americanum
and C. dendroides, respectively) than the mean genetic identity betwe
en the species (0.814). Levels of variation within populations were ve
ry low. The two species differed significantly in leaf cell length-wid
th ratios and leaf auricle size, but there was substantial overlap bet
ween them. Our results indicate that C. americanum and C. dendroides a
re evolutionarily distinct, reproductively isolated species despite a
lack of complete morphological discontinuity. We found no evidence tha
t morphological intergradation is caused by interspecific hybridizatio
n.