This article develops a framework that encompasses past two-sided pers
uasion research and incorporates additional theory and research on opt
imal arousal and attitude toward the ad to provide explanations for in
consistencies in previous findings. In particular, explanations are pr
ovided for the following: (1) when credibility gains will be enhanced,
(2) when refutation is needed, (3) how the message should be structur
ed (in terms of amount and placement of negative information), and (4)
what types of attributes should be discounted (in terms of importance
, type, and correlation with other attributes). In addition, direction
s for future research are discussed.