Computed radiography was used to make radiogrammetric measurements of
the second metacarpal in 240 women, 180 considered normal and 60 osteo
porotic. These measurements had a coefficient of variation for the ext
ernal diameter of 0.74% in normal women and 0.75% in osteoporotic wome
n, and for the internal diameter of 2.4% and 2.03%, respectively. The
group of women with osteoporosis was divided according to external dia
meter and internal diameter into a group with osteoporosis due to incr
eased bone resorption (61.1%, normal external diameter and increased i
nternal diameter), and osteoporosis due to deficient bone formation (2
6.1%, decreased external diameter and normal internal diameter). In th
e remaining subjects (12.8%), osteoporosis was attributed to both mech
anisms. There was a significant linear regression between internal dia
meter and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase concentration (p < 0.000
1) in the group of increased bone resorption, which was absent (p = ns
) in the group with deficient bone mass formation. No changes were obs
erved in the size of the two groups. The low coefficient of variation
of radiogrammetric measurements with computed radiography validate it
as an accurate technique for bone mass studies. Moreover, it has the a
dditional advantage of permitting determination of the proportion of w
omen with osteoporosis due to increased bone resorption and/or deficie
nt bone mass formation.