EVALUATION OF SERUM CREATININE FOR ESTIMATING GLOMERULAR-FILTRATION RATE IN AFRICAN-AMERICANS WITH HYPERTENSIVE NEPHROSCLEROSIS - RESULTS FROM THE AFRICAN-AMERICAN STUDY OF KIDNEY-DISEASE AND HYPERTENSION (AASK) PILOT-STUDY
Rd. Toto et al., EVALUATION OF SERUM CREATININE FOR ESTIMATING GLOMERULAR-FILTRATION RATE IN AFRICAN-AMERICANS WITH HYPERTENSIVE NEPHROSCLEROSIS - RESULTS FROM THE AFRICAN-AMERICAN STUDY OF KIDNEY-DISEASE AND HYPERTENSION (AASK) PILOT-STUDY, Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 8(2), 1997, pp. 279-287
Measurement of GFR is considered the standard for estimating renal fun
ction. However, standardized accurate GFR methodology is expensive and
cumbersome; therefore, estimates of GFR based on serum creatinine con
centration have been employed. The purpose of the study presented here
was to assess the accuracy and precision of using serum creatinine me
asurements to estimate GFR in the screenee cohort of The African-Ameri
can Study of Kidney Disease and Hypertension (AASK) Pilot Study. GFR w
as estimated by four methods: 100/serum creatinine, Cockcroft-Gault eq
uation, creatinine clearance from 24-h urine collection, and a new reg
ression equation derived from the pilot study data. These methods were
compared with renal clearance of I-125-iothalamate GFR (GFR1) in 193
hypertensive (diastolic blood pressure greater than or equal to 95 mm
Hg) African-American screenees (142 men, 51 women). A second GFR (GFR2
) was performed in 98 screenees who were eligible (GFR1 25-70 mL/min p
er 1.73 m(2)) for the pilot study. Accuracy was assessed by the differ
ence of I-125-iothalamate GFR-estimated GFR (Delta GFR), and precision
was estimated from the combined root mean squared error (CRMSE) and t
he coefficient of determination (r(2)) The results for accuracy (+/- S
D) and precision were as follows: (1)100/Scr, Delta GFR = -0.76 +/- 16
.5, CRMSE = 16.5, r(2) = 0.69; (2) Cockcroft- Gault, Delta GFR = 9.56
+/- 14.9, CRMSE = 17.7, r(2) = 0.66; 3) 24-h creatinine clearance, Del
ta GFR = 0.79 +/-i 20.7, CRMSE = 20.7, r(2) = 0.49; 4) New equation De
lta GFR = -0.08 +/- 12.8, CRMSE 12.7, r(2) = 0.75. In comparison, a se
cond GFR (GFR2, N = 98) had Delta GFR = 1.36 +/- 8.48, CRMSE 8.6, r(2)
= 0.75. Estimates based on 100/SCr and the new equation were the most
precise. It was concluded that GFR estimated by serum creatinine is s
uperior to outpatient 24-h urine creatinine clearance in this populati
on. Serum creatinine values can be used to provide a reasonably accura
te estimate of GFR in hypertensive African Americans.