A controversial technique for testing the hypothesis that physicians i
nduce demand involves two stage least squares (TSLS) regression analys
is of cross-section data on physician supply and utilization. This pap
er tests the power of TSLS by applying it where there is at most only
a trivial amount of demand inducement - the demand for childbirths. We
find 'evidence' of inducement of childbirths, calling into question t
he validity of the TSLS approach. This unlikely finding may be traced
to at least two factors: The first stage regression is not identified
and the second stage regression does not adequately address border cro
ssing.