Mc. Pittalis et al., THE PREDICTIVE VALUE OF CYTOGENETIC DIAGNOSIS AFTER CVS BASED ON 4860CASES WITH BOTH DIRECT AND CULTURE METHODS, Prenatal diagnosis, 14(4), 1994, pp. 267-278
Cytogenetic analysis was performed in 4860 chorionic villus samples by
means of both direct preparation and long-term culture. The results o
f the analysis were compared with a classification including all theor
etical types of combinations between the chromosomal constitution of t
he cytotrophoblast, extraembryonal mesoderm, and fetus, with the aim o
f evaluating the cytogenetic variability along the trophoblast-embryo
axis. Eighteen of 29 possible combinations were found demonstrating a
considerable heterogeneity. A mosaic conceptus was found in 1.5 per ce
nt of cases, with generalized mosaicisms and confined mosaicisms in 0.
2 and 1.3 per cent, respectively. Cytogenetic variability along the tr
ophoblast-embryo axis was found in 1.42 per cent of cases. Results pos
sibly leading to diagnostic errors (false-positive and false-negative
results) were found in only 1.38 per cent. False-positive results of d
irect preparation were the most commonly observed discrepancy (0.8 per
cent), while the incidence of false-positive results of the culture m
ethod and of both methods was 0.31 and 0.16 per cent respectively. The
incidence of false-negative results was 0.1 per cent, with false-nega
tive results of direct preparation 0.08 per cent and false-negative re
sults of both methods 0.02 per cent. False-negative results of the cul
ture method were not found. Our data confirm the high diagnostic accur
acy of chorionic villus sampling and the utility of the combined use o
f the two methods in minimizing diagnostic errors and in reducing the
need for follow-up amniocentesis.