Ms. Moran et al., USE OF GROUND-BASED REMOTELY-SENSED DATA FOR SURFACE-ENERGY BALANCE EVALUATION OF A SEMIARID RANGELAND, Water resources research, 30(5), 1994, pp. 1339-1349
An interdisciplinary field experiment was conducted to study the water
and energy balance of a semiarid rangeland watershed in southeast Ari
zona during the summer of 1990. Two subwatersheds, one grass dominated
and the other shrub dominated, were selected for intensive study with
ground-based remote sensing systems and hydrometeorological instrumen
tation. Surface energy balance was evaluated at both sites using direc
t and indirect measurements of the turbulent fluxes (eddy correlation,
variance, and Bowen ratio methods) and using an aerodynamic approach
based on remote measurements of surface reflectance and temperature an
d conventional meteorological information. Estimates of net radiant fl
ux density (R(n)), derived from measurements of air temperature, incom
ing solar radiation, and surface temperature and radiance compared wel
l with values measured using a net radiometer (mean absolute differenc
e (MAD) congruent-to 50 W/m2 over a range from 115 to 670 W/m2). Soil
heat flux density (G) was estimated using a relation between G/R(n) an
d a spectral vegetation index computed from the red and near-infrared
surface reflectance. These G estimates compared well with conventional
measurements of G using buried soil heat flux plates (MAD congruent-t
o 20 W/m2 over a range from - 13 to 213 W/m2). In order to account for
the effects of sparse vegetation, semiempirical adjustments to the si
ngle-layer bulk aerodynamic resistance approach were required for eval
uation of sensible heat flux density (H). This yielded differences bet
ween measurements and remote estimates of H of approximately 33 W/m2 o
ver a range from 13 to 303 W/m2. The resulting estimates of latent hea
t flux density, LE, were of the same magnitude and trend as measured v
alues; however, a significant scatter was still observed: MAD congruen
t-to 40 W/M2 over a range from 0 to 340 W/m2. Because LE was solved as
a residual, there was a cumulative effect of errors associated with r
emote estimates of R(n), G, and H.