Yp. Kalra et al., FORESTRY CANADA INTERLABORATORY STUDY FOR THE ANALYSIS OF PLANT MATERIALS, Communications in soil science and plant analysis, 25(9-10), 1994, pp. 1517-1525
Eighteen laboratories participated in this round-robin performance tes
t, commissioned by the Quality Assurance Sub-roup, to assure comparabi
lity of results in the inorganic constituents in plant materials. Each
laboratory was provided with an identical set of ten oven-dried, blin
d audit samples (sets included foliage, bark, stem wood and leaf litte
r), and was asked to analyze the samples for total concentrations of C
, N, P, K, Ca, M-, S, Fe, Mn, B, Zn, Cu, Mo, Cl, Na, Al, Ni, Pb, Cd, H
-, Co, and As. The data were analyzed for group statistics (means, med
ians, standard deviations and standard errors by sample and element) a
nd distributed to the participants for selfevaluation. Laboratory conf
identiality was maintained throughout. On average, coefficients of var
iation suggested reasonable reproducibility among laboratories with re
spect to C, P, K, Ca, M-, Cu, and Al; some laboratory-to-laboratory va
riation with respect to N, S, Fe, Mn, and Zn; and considerable laborat
ory-to-laboratory variation with regard to other elements. In general,
samples with low concentrations presented difficulties.