A study of female reproductive histories from nineteenth-century Utah
shows that although women who married polygynously had fewer children,
their number of grandchildren was equal to that of women who married
monogamously. Women who chose to marry high-status men polygynously tr
aded decreased fertility for enhanced reproductive performance of offs
pring. High status can be associated with low fertility and yet still
be consistent with fitness optimization. These results suggest how fem
ale reproductive decisions influence social structure and challenge pr
evious assumptions concerning proximate measures of fitness.