This paper compares the accuracy of college freshmen self-reported inf
ormation about financial aid awards with actual data on the types and
amounts of these awards. Data from the 1986-87 National Postsecondary
Aid Study (NPSAS) file are replicated with evidence from a single inst
itution. The study shows that college freshmen are relatively accurate
in reporting whether any financial aid was received. However, student
s' self-reports of specific financial aid awards and amounts do not co
rrespond closely to actual data. Campus administrators would come to v
ery different conclusions about both the types and amounts of student
aid if they rely on survey data compared to actual data. The results p
rovide evidence for how nonsampling errors may bias survey results.