Dm. Willis et al., UNCERTAINTIES IN FIELD-LINE TRACING IN THE MAGNETOSPHERE .2. THE COMPLETE INTERNAL GEOMAGNETIC-FIELD, Annales geophysicae, 15(2), 1997, pp. 181-196
The discussion in the preceding paper is restricted to the uncertainti
es in magnetic-field-line tracing in the magnetosphere resulting from
published standard errors in the spherical harmonic coefficients that
define the axisymmetric part of the internal geomagnetic field (i.e. g
(n)(0) +/- delta g(n)(0)). Numerical estimates of these uncertainties
based on an analytic equation for axisymmetric field lines are in exce
llent agreement with independent computational estimates based on step
wise numerical integration along magnetic field lines. This comparison
confirms the accuracy of the computer program used in the present pap
er to estimate the uncertainties in magnetic-field-line tracing that a
rise from published standard errors in the full set of spherical harmo
nic coefficients, which define the complete (non-axisymmetric) interna
l geomagnetic field (i.e. g(n)(m) +/- delta g(n)(m)) and h(n)(m) +/- d
elta h(n)(m)). An algorithm is formulated that greatly reduces the com
puting time required to estimate these uncertainties in magnetic-field
-line tracing. The validity of this algorithm is checked numerically f
or both the axisymmetric part of the internal geomagnetic field in the
general case (1 less than or equal to n less than or equal to 10) and
the complete internal geomagnetic field in a restrictive case (0 less
than or equal to m less than or equal to n, 1 less than or equal to n
less than or equal to 3). On this basis it is assumed that the algori
thm can be used with confidence in those cases for which the computing
time would otherwise be prohibitively long. For the complete internal
geomagnetic field, the maximum characteristic uncertainty in the geoc
entric distance of a held line that crosses the geomagnetic equator at
a nominal dipolar distance of 2 R(E) is typically 100 km. The corresp
onding characteristic uncertainty for a field line that crosses the ge
omagnetic equator at a nominal dipolar distance of 6 R(E) is typically
500 km. Histograms and scatter plots showing the characteristic uncer
tainties associated with magnetic-field-line tracing in the magnetosph
ere are presented for a range of illustrative examples. Finally, estim
ates are given for the maximum uncertainties in the locations of the c
onjugate points of selected geophysical observatories. Numerical estim
ates of the uncertainties in magnetic-field-line tracing in the magnet
osphere, including the associated uncertainties in the locations of th
e conjugate points of geophysical observatories, should be regarded as
''first approximations'' in the sense that these estimates are only a
s accurate as the published standard errors in the full set of spheric
al harmonic coefficients. As in the preceding paper, however, all comp
utational techniques developed in this paper can be used to derive mor
e realistic estimates of the uncertainties in magnetic-field-line trac
ing in the magnetosphere, following further progress in the determinat
ion of more accurate standard errors in the spherical harmonic coeffic
ients.