BECAUSE their molecular signatures are often prominent in extracts of
sediments, bacteria are thought to be important contributors to petrol
eum source beds(1). It has been shown recently(2,3), however, that abu
ndances of biomarkers do not always reflect relative contributions to
sedimentary organic carbon (C-org). The contribution of photosynthetic
green sulphur bacteria to sediments can be assessed effectively becau
se the diagenetic products of distinctive carotenoids from these organ
isms occur widely(4-11) and their biomass is isotopically labelled, be
ing enriched in C-13 (refs 11, 13). We show here that, although sedime
nts and oils from the Western Canada and Williston basins contain prom
inent biomarkers of photosynthetic bacteria, the absence of C-13 enric
hment in the total C-org requires that the bacterial contribution is i
n fact minimal. Although the importance of bacterial reworking of sedi
mentary debris cannot be doubted(14), we argue that our findings, when
considered in conjunction with those from other settings, suggest tha
t bacterial biomass may commonly represent only a minor component of t
otal C-org in carbonaceous rocks.