The Michael Initiated Ring Closure reaction has been explored with an
eye toward achieving asymmetric induction. The formation of three, fiv
e and six-membered rings was examined using compounds 1-7 as substrate
s. In the case of cyclopropane formation, diastereoselectivity was stu
died over a range of temperatures, the best results being obtained bet
ween -68 and -72 degrees C using lithium 1-buthylthiolate as the nucle
ophile and a 10-dicyclohexylsulfamoyl-D-isoborneol-derived auxiliary (
72-78% yield, 50-56% de; note equation 5). An isokinetic point is beli
eved to occur between -41 and -68 degrees C. No improvement in de was
observed when the Oppolzer sultam was used instead (compound 18). The
use of (-)-menthol and (-)-8-phenylmenthol derived auxiliaries led to
substantially inferior results (2-6% de). Five and six-membered rings
were formed in good to excellent yields (62-97%) with diastereometric
excesses reaching as high as 95% in the case of cyclohexyl ester forma
tion, using lithium diisopropylamide as the nucleophile and the 10-dic
yclohexylsulamoyl-D-isoborneol-derived auxiliary. Note equations 7 and
8. As expected, cyclization affording the five-membered ring adducts
proceeded substantially faster than those leading to the six. By condu
cting both reactions at low temperature, one can use this rate differe
nce to assess the diastereomeric excess obtained in the conjugate addi
tion of LDA to the six-membered ring precursor 7. The de obtained in t
his manner (ca 95%) agreed within experimental error with that obtaine
d when the reaction was conducted at a low temperature where cyclizati
on occurred.