Collapse conditions for large expanding shells and rings in a disk gal
axy are derived and shown to lead to a condition for star formation th
at is similar to the condition Q < 1 for spontaneous instabilities. Th
is result implies that both spontaneous and stimulated star formation
are sensitive to Q, and that the observation of a critical surface den
sity for star formation that is based on Q does not necessarily imply
that star formation results from large-scale quiescent instabilities.
The results also suggest that in regions with high gas densities and h
igh rotation rates, such as starburst galaxy nuclei, the normal balanc
e between stimulated and spontaneous star formation mechanisms could s
hift to give a higher proportion of stars forming in shells and other
swept-up debris, and less in giant cloud complexes containing the loca
l Jeans mass.