Gram-negative bacteria release lipopolysaccharide (endotoxin) that cau
ses sepsis and septic shock. Monoclonal antibodies against endotoxins
have been proposed as a treatment of sepsis. One such antibody, nebacu
mab (HA-1A), was released onto the market in some European countries a
nd its approval in the USA was recommended. However, doubts raised by
the lack of reproducible preclinical data, and by an independent reana
lysis of the results of the first clinical trial, led to a further cli
nical trial. This second trial revealed an increase in mortality in ne
bacumab-treated patients. The trial was stopped and the drug withdrawn
from the market. To avoid such disappointments, the marketing of new
biotechnology products should be based on critical scientific analysis
, free from commercial pressures, of thorough, reproducible and consis
tent preclinical and clinical studies.