Rb. Goldstein et al., PSYCHIATRIC-DISORDERS IN RELATIVES OF PROBANDS WITH PANIC DISORDER AND OR MAJOR DEPRESSION/, Archives of general psychiatry, 51(5), 1994, pp. 383-394
Background: Panic disorder and major depression (MDD) are both highly
familial disorders that co-occur in individuals but do not cosegregate
in families. Evidence concerning their familial aggregation with othe
r psychiatric disorders, including phobias, substance abuse, and antis
ocial personality, has been contradictory. In part, the contradictory
findings may be due to failure to account for the effects of proband c
omorbidity on risks in relatives. Methods: A family study of 1047 adul
t first-degree relatives of 193 probands in four diagnostic groups (pa
nic disorder without MDD, panic disorder plus MDD, early-onset MDD, an
d screened normal controls) was used to determine the range of psychia
tric disorders associated with panic disorder and MDD and the effects
of proband comorbidity on the rates of disorders in relatives. Results
: Compared to relatives of normal controls, relatives of probands with
panic disorder or panic disorder and MDD showed significantly increas
ed risks of panic disorder, but relatives of probands with early-onset
MDD did not. After proband comorbidity was controlled for, relatives
of probands with panic disorder were also at a significantly increased
risk for social phobia but not for any other psychiatric disorders. R
elatives of probands with early-onset MDD were at significantly increa
sed risks for MDD, dysthymia, abuse of or dependence on alcohol and ot
her drugs, and antisocial personality disorders but not for any other
psychiatric disorders. Conclusions: We conclude that panic disorder is
a specific familial entity that is not associated with a broad range
of other anxiety or other psychiatric disorders, with the possible exc
eption of social phobia. Dysthymia, substance abuse, and antisocial pe
rsonality appear to be on the spectrum of early-onset MDD.