From the original Downs (1957) conceptualization to the Enelow and Hin
ich (1984) reformulation, ideology has been the key organizing dimensi
on for electoral competition in the spatial model. The unidimensional
spatial model is best suited to responsible multiparty systems where l
eft-right position is known to be an important determinant of individu
al political behaviour. We contrast the traditional spatial model with
the directional model recently proposed by Rabinowitz and Macdonald (
1989) and test the models using data from six northern European democr
acies. Based on 57 different parties, the results suggest that even in
this unidimensional ideological context the cleavage-oriented directi
onal model provides a better explanation of mass attachments to politi
cal parties.