Mjf. Kool et al., EVALUATION OF REPRODUCIBILITY OF A VESSEL WALL MOVEMENT DETECTOR SYSTEM FOR ASSESSMENT OF LARGE ARTERY PROPERTIES, Cardiovascular Research, 28(5), 1994, pp. 610-614
Objective: Arterial distensibility (DC) and compliance (CC) are vessel
wall properties of large arteries that can be measured non-invasively
with a custom made vessel wall movement detector system (VWMDS). This
study investigated the reproducibility of this device in 10 volunteer
s. Methods: To investigate intraobserver intrasession and intraobserve
r intersession variability, arterial diameter (D) and relative change
in diameter during the heart cycle (Delta D/D) were measured in the el
astic common carotid artery, and in the muscular femoral and brachial
arteries. Interobserver intrasession variability was examined in commo
n carotid artery by two observers, while interobserver variability on
the same image was assessed for common carotid and femoral arteries. V
ariability was expressed as the coefficient of variation. Results: For
common carotid artery, intraobserver intrasession variability was 7.9
(SEM 1.6)% (Delta D/D), 4.5(1.1)% (D), 8.3(1.3)% (DC), and 9.1(2.6)% (
CC), respectively. In femoral artery it was 12.4(2.2)% (Delta D/D), 2.
7(0.6)% (D), 13.4(2.2)% (DC), and 12.5(2.1)% (CC). For brachial artery
it was 13.4(2.8)% (Delta D/D), 2.5(0.5)% (D), 16.1(2.5)% (DC), and 15
.6(2.6)% (CC). Intraobserver intersession variability was comparable t
o intraobserver intrasession variability for all vessels. Interobserve
r intrasession variability for common carotid artery was 11.3(2.6)% (D
elta D/D) and 8.6(1.9)% (D), but was larger for DC and CC. Interobserv
er variability on the same image was <5% for common carotid and femora
l arteries. Conclusions: In conclusion, the vessel wall movement detec
tor system has a good technical reproducibility. Intraobserver intrase
ssion and intersession variability are comparable, and are larger in m
uscular arteries. This might be due to a larger variation in tone of t
hese arteries, which are under permanent neurohumoral control. Interob
server intrasession variability was larger than intraobserver variabil
ity and might be influenced by differences in observers' skill and spo
ntaneous variation in vessel wall properties.