Mj. Reid et al., EFFECTS OF MATERNAL DISTRACTION AND REPRIMANDS ON TODDLERS TRANSGRESSIONS AND NEGATIVE AFFECT, Journal of abnormal child psychology, 22(2), 1994, pp. 237-245
Misbehaviors occur at a high rate during the toddler years, and parent
s use a variety of methods to control these behaviors. The present inv
estigation compared the effectiveness of two commonly used strategies,
distraction and reprimands. Twenty mothers and their 17- to 39-month-
old children were observed in a laboratory setting in which mothers us
ed either distraction then reprimands or reprimands followed by distra
ction in response to their children's transgressions. When reprimands
were used as the initial strategy, they were significantly more effect
ive than distraction in controlling children's transgressions. Distrac
tion was effective in maintaining low rates of transgression when prec
eded by a period of reprimands. However, when reprimands were institut
ed following a period of distraction, children's rates of negative aff
ect increased significantly. Implications for the etiology and managem
ent of child behavior problems are discussed.