Recent studies suggest that grain content may not necessarily predict
corn (Zea mays L.) forage quality. Field studies were conducted at two
New York locations in 1991 and 1992 to evaluate forage quality differ
ences among commercial corn hybrids across different growing condition
s and the relationship between the harvest index (HI) value and forage
quality. Twelve hybrids, which ranged in relative maturity from 95 to
116 d, were evaluated in two experiments according to maturity differ
ences. Each hybrid was hand-harvested at the 1/2-milk-line stage or 35
0 g kg-1 dry matter (DM) concentration to determine DM yield, HI, whol
e-plant N, neutral-detergent fiber (NDF), acid-detergent fiber (ADF),
lignin, and in vitro true digestibility (IVTD). Although the relations
hip among hybrids for NDF was consistent across three of four site-yea
r comparisons, year x hybrid and location x hybrid interactions existe
d in one experiment because some hybrids received a killing frost at o
ne location before attaining the 1/2-milk-line stage. In contrast, hyb
rid interactions for IVTD did not exist, which suggests a consistent r
elationship among hybrids for digestibility, even if hybrids received
a killing frost between the dent and 1/2-milk-line stage. The HI corre
lated closely with NDF (-0.84 and -0.82) and IVTD (0.79 and 0.63) in b
oth experiments. Likewise, lignin correlated closely with NDF (0.84 an
d 0.88) and IVTD (-0.76 and -0.79). The data suggest that livestock pr
oducers can continue to choose hybrids with high grain content if rela
tively low fiber and high digestibility are of prime interest.