Gm. Bernstein et al., TESTS OF THE TULLY-FISHER RELATION .1. SCATTER IN INFRARED MAGNITUDE VERSUS 21 CM WIDTH, The Astronomical journal, 107(6), 1994, pp. 1962-1976
We examine the precision of the Tully-Fisher relation (TFR) using a sa
mple of galaxies in the Coma region of the sky, and find that it is go
od to 5% or better in measuring relative distances. Total magnitudes a
nd disk axis ratios are derived from H and I band surface photometry,
and Arecibo 21 cm profiles define the rotation speeds of the galaxies.
Using 25 galaxies for which the disk inclination and 21 cm width are
well defined, we find an rms deviation of 0.10 mag from a linear TFR w
ith dI/d(log W(c)) = -5.6. Each galaxy is assumed to be at a distance
proportional to its redshift, and an extinction correction of 1.4(1 -
b/a) mag is applied to the total I magnitude. The measured scatter is
<0.15 mag using milder extinction laws from the literature. The I band
TFR scatter is consistent with measurement error, and the 95% CL limi
ts on the intrinsic scatter are 0-0.10 mag. The rms scatter using H ba
nd magnitudes is 0.20 mag (N=17). The low width galaxies have scatter
in H significantly in excess of known measurement error, but the highe
r width half of the galaxies have scatter consistent with measurement
error. The H band TFR slope may be as steep as the I band slope. As th
e first applications of this tight correlation, we note the following:
(1) the data for the particular spirals commonly used to define the T
FR distance to the Coma cluster are inconsistent with being at a commo
n distance and are in fact in free Hubble expansion, with an upper lim
it of 300 km s-1 on the rms peculiar line-of-sight velocity of these g
as-rich spirals; and (2) the gravitational potential in the disks of t
hese galaxies has typical ellipticity <5%. The published data for thre
e nearby spiral galaxies with Cepheid distance determinations are inco
nsistent with our Coma TFR, suggesting that these local calibrators ar
e either ill-measured or peculiar relative to the Coma Supercluster sp
irals, or that the TFR has a varying form in different locales.