The empirical development of a Normative Message Processing Scale (NMP
S) is presented. An argument is made for the need to develop an instru
ment that distinguishes between the tendency to engage in message proc
essing that is selective, effortful, and highly deliberate and message
processing that is unselective, low effort, and nondeliberate. Becaus
e self reported differences in exerted cognitive effort may indicate b
oth quantitative and qualitative differences in message processing, ef
fort-based instruments do not allow specific predictions regarding the
processing habits of low effort individuals. Understanding and measur
ing the processing characteristics of high and low effort individuals
may explain observed differences in performances between individuals w
ith a high or low need for cognition and between individuals induced t
o perform in a mindful or mindless manner. Five studies are presented,
reporting on the development, conceptual validation, and behavioral v
alidation of the NMPS. In addition, the conceptual and predictive vali
dity of the NMPS is compared to related trait information-processing i
nstruments. The usefulness of the NMPS in communication research is di
scussed.